Whitehorse Daily Star

Fined guide ‘truly embarrassed and ashamed’

An experienced hunting guide from Alberta who spent last summer working for a Yukon outfitter has been fined $10,000 for offences under the territory’s Wildlife Act.

By Rhiannon Russell on August 1, 2014

An experienced hunting guide from Alberta who spent last summer working for a Yukon outfitter has been fined $10,000 for offences under the territory’s Wildlife Act.

Patrick Garrett, 39, pleaded guilty in territorial court this morning to the illegal hunting of a grizzly and a caribou and failing to prevent a contravention of the act.

Represented by defence lawyer Mike Reynolds, Garrett did not appear in court.

That’s because he was working at a remote site northern B.C. in order to pay off the fine, which was a joint submission by Reynolds and Crown prosecutor Lee Kirkpatrick.

“In 26 years, I’ve never made a mistake like this, and I’m truly embarrassed and ashamed it happened,” Garrett wrote in a statement Reynolds read aloud before Judge Murray Hinds.

Garrett was working last summer as a guide in the Tombstone Territorial Park area for one of the territory’s outfitters.

He’s an experienced hunter and guide and runs his own guiding business in Alberta.

Kirkpatrick said Garrett participated in the pre-season guiding talk which discusses Yukon rules and laws. One is that an outfitter can only have one person hunting with him or her at a time.

On Aug. 27, Garrett headed north on the Dempster Highway with two men. The plan was one of the men was just along for the ride, but he did a bring a gun.

(Reynolds said his client recalls the outfitter instructing him to bring both men out, while, according to the outfitter’s version of events, recounted by Kirkpatrick, they told Garrett if the second man brought a gun, he could not use it.)

The group spotted a grizzly bear off the highway, and the man assigned to Garrett shot and killed it.

Kirkpatrick said grizzly hunting is prohibited in an eight-kilometre corridor along the Dempster. This bear was less than one kilometre from the highway.

On the way back to camp, the men spotted a caribou. The second man shot at it, but missed.

Reynolds said that when Garrett arrived back at camp, the outfitter confronted him and told him he shouldn’t have had two men out with him, and that the grizzly killing was illegal because of its proximity to the highway.

He had “feelings of disbelief and a feeling like he was going to be sick to his stomach,” Reynolds said.

Garrett does not recall the pre-season guiding talk.

In the past, he had had poor, “almost ambiguous” communication with the outfitter.

“But as a guide, Mr. Garrett knows the ultimate blame and responsibility lies with him,” Reynolds said.

Hinds accepted the joint submission.

Garrett must pay $5,000 for the illegal grizzly hunting, $4,000 for the illegal caribou hunting and $1,000 for failing to prevent a contravention of the Wildlife Act.

He is prohibited from guiding in the Yukon for seven years, and must complete the Hunter Education and Ethics Development program before obtaining a guiding licence in the territory.

His fine will serve as a contribution to the Yukon Fish and Game Association.

As for the man who had been assigned to Garrett on that hunt, Kirkpatrick said the outfitter has offered him a return hunt, because he paid about $20,000 for the trip and his grizzly trophy was forfeited to the Yukon government.


Due to incorrect information provided to the Star, a story in Tuesday’s edition reported that James Colosimo killed a Dall sheep and a Stone sheep while on two hunts with James Richards in the Yukon.

In fact, Colosimo killed a Dall sheep on one of these hunts. He did not admit to killing the Stone sheep, only to being involved in its export.

Comments (7)

Up 3 Down 4

kevin on Nov 29, 2014 at 3:54 pm

I have known this person for years. He was the youngest hunter to reach the North American hunting grand slam. Deep down I always thought it was not legit. I wonder how many critters were actually poached, we will never know but I will bet you a few looks good on him. I love it

Up 3 Down 0

John on Sep 23, 2014 at 7:58 am

Pretty amazing that anyone here can assert that just because someone isn't born in the Yukon that they have no "vested interest" in the place. First, I suspect some have been around longer than a lot of people reading this, even Yukon natives, have been alive. Further, it seems to me that a multi-million dollar investment in a guide territory very clearly constitutes a "vested interest" in the sustainability of an area! Pretty good incentive to manage wildlife properly and follow applicable laws I would say!

Up 5 Down 1

BWC on Sep 5, 2014 at 7:57 am

Interesting this arcticle and the comments provided. First of all how interesting it is that some people providing comments can be so narrow minded like Francine Pillman. Would the same rational that you are speaking about apply to impaired drivers or speeders? Those Yukoners or others breaking driving laws in other Provinces shouldn't be allow back? Are you for real to focus on a wildlife infraction and not consider greater law breaking offences?
Poor decisions made by Mr. Garrett, same choices made by Yukoners every year as well. He deserves what he got no question! Unfortunate that some Yukoners can assume outsiders are all bad people. Maybe we should have boarder guards at each Territory or Province?

Up 12 Down 29

Chris Gerritse on Sep 2, 2014 at 8:14 am

Couldn't have "happened" to a nicer guy. It's about time this guys poaching caught up to him.

Up 32 Down 6

Francine Pillman on Aug 3, 2014 at 12:00 pm

Sad and embarrassed you got caught. You don't deserve to step back in the Yukon ever.

Up 18 Down 4

Josey Wales on Aug 2, 2014 at 11:25 pm

Good on DoE for kickin' it up a notch lately! Unfortunately the message I've been getting is that regular criminal matters are not taken in our courts seriously as wildlife infractions.

Up 33 Down 20

BnR on Aug 1, 2014 at 5:42 pm

Beside the "old school" Yukoners, like Widrig outfitters and Dickson outfitters, the rest are Albertans, British Columbians and others with no vested interest in the Yukon, or the sustainability of our wildlife. It's just a playground for them, a place to cash in.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.