‘We need to stand up against this'
About 75 people took to the streets of Whitehorse Wednesday evening to stand in solidarity with striking students in Quebec.
By Max Leighton on May 31, 2012
About 75 people took to the streets of Whitehorse Wednesday evening to stand in solidarity with striking students in Quebec.
The Quebec students have been protesting planned university tuition increases since February, when the provincial government announced a 75-per-cent increase in tuition fees to be phased in over the next five years.
Despite paying the lowest tuitions in Canada, students in Quebec say their concern is mounting student debt in increasingly challenging job markets.
The protesters have been met with police action, and earlier this month, the passing of Bill 78, an emergency law which greatly restricts freedom of assembly without prior police approval.
Solidarity marches have been held across Canada, in New York City and several locations worldwide.
The Whitehorse demonstration began at 8 p.m. on the steps of the Elijah Smith Building.
In an event dubbed "Casseroles Whitehorse”, Wednesday's organizers, Owen Williams and Lewis Rifkind, encouraged people to bang on pots and pans, offering a loud collective response to the treatment of the students more than 5,500 kilometres away.
"Pots and pans are easy and they're elegant, and everyone knows how to beat pots and pans by the time they are five,” Williams said in an interview today.
The event was predominantly organized through the group's facebook page, which had an attendance list of nearly 100 by last evening.
"It was an attempt to show that people oppose what is being done by the Quebec government,” said Williams.
"I am concerned about austerity cuts and, of course, am sympathetic to the Quebec students, but I am also concerned with Bill 78 and that something like that could be passed anywhere in Canada.”
The sound of banging pots and pans is being heard by students in Quebec, said Williams.
"Quite a few members of the francophone community came out and people were following online from Montreal,” he said.
"Bill 78 is a basic violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"From the perspective of outside media, both the Guardian and the New York Times described as draconian. Amnesty International described it as a violation of our basic rights. We need to stand up against this.”
The march proceeded down Main Street and returned to Elijah Smith by about 9 p.m.
"I thought it would be over in five or 10 minutes,” said Williams. "After about five minutes, we started banging the pots and pans.
"One thing that surprised me, though, was that everyone stayed on the right-hand side of the road. We did stop traffic, though, and saw a lot of support from people on the street.”
At one point, Premier Darrell Pasloski passed through the march.
"I think he was heading home to get his pots and pans,” Rifkind quipped this morning.
Rifkind graduated in 1989, back when tuition cost $1,300 and students were barely able to pay it if they found a "good summer job,” he said.
The Whitehorse organizers say they share the core beliefs of the student protest.
"Today, with the amount of debt students are graduating with, we are basically creating a generation of indentured servants who are forced to work either in government or for big corporations,” said Rifkind.
"Setting the system up so students have huge debt loads when they graduate is basically guaranteeing that people will have to gravitate only to the fields where they will get lots of money.
"That's not entirely a bad thing. We need doctors, lawyers and people like that, but we also need people in the fine arts to have a fully-functioning society.”
Opposition to Bill 78 also runs high among local organizers.
"I grew up in apartheid South Africa, where there was huge repression,” Rifkind said.
"Once you put that kind of restriction on one segment of society, no matter how small, you're putting it on all of us.”
It's a sentiment both Williams and Rifkind believe is shared by many others in the community.
"People were generally pleased that this was happening,” said Williams.
"One thing I was concerned about was that these issues raise a lot of anger in people, but actually, the event was very positive.”
There are other reasons to get out and protest as well, he said.
"It's amazing how loud pots and pans can be,” said Rifkind. "And walking around banging pots and pans is amazingly therapeutic.”
Whitehorse residents should get used to the sound of banging cookware.
The demonstrators plan to continue to meet every Wednesday at 8 p.m. in front of the Elijah Smith Building, as long as the Quebec protest continues.
See the latest on the dispute in Quebec
Comments (13)
Up 1 Down 0
Mark Radke on Jun 1, 2012 at 12:34 pm
I really think people need to gain a bit of perspective here.
Days after dozens of Syrian children were murdered in their homes, Yukoners joined together to bang pots in support of students protesting modest tuition increases in Quebec.
Really? This is the pressing issue of the day?
Up 1 Down 0
Illegal assembly on Jun 1, 2012 at 4:29 am
Where are the police to stop the closure of the road this caused? The tourists must really love to see this kind of idiotic and useless protesting
Up 1 Down 0
Think they'd care about us? on May 31, 2012 at 11:24 pm
Here's my one question, you think Quebec student would go out protesting and banging their pots and pans if it was happening up here? NOT LIKELY...
Up 1 Down 0
Jaymanc on May 31, 2012 at 9:23 pm
Hey get off the road theres a cross walk, USE IT! This protesting is getting really retarded. Sounds like a bunch of babies who can't have what they want. Hmm sounds like some of the politicians we have here too.
Up 1 Down 0
north_of_60 on May 31, 2012 at 5:58 pm
These harmless and amusing people are 'protesting' because that's what passes for entertainment in their social milieu. What they're protesting against this time isn't important, it's all about the 'protest process'. They love the media attention, it makes them feel important.
Up 0 Down 0
Luigi Zanasi on May 31, 2012 at 2:59 pm
When I was a student in Quebec in the 70s, I got a much better deal than students get today and managed to actually come out of school debt-free. I for one would accept paying higher taxes to reduce tuition right across Canada. Those kids are the ones who will be working to pay for my pension, just like I am now paying for current retirees.
And government spending on education is not spending, it is an investment with a fairly high rate of return to taxpayers. The OECD calcualted that the social rate of return for tertiary (i.e. post secondary) education in Canada was 6.8% to 7.9% PER YEAR over the working life of the students.
Up 1 Down 0
Geoff Capp on May 31, 2012 at 2:43 pm
These malcontent students don't seem to realize they have the lowest tuitions in Canada. They seem to have been denied an important part of parental love: the word "no". No, you can't have everything. No, because we don't have the money. And no, the government can't pay your tuition because the only money the government has is tax money from taxpayers, which you are supposed to one day become, and then you won't like the idea of paying higher taxes so others can have freebies like the ones you're asking for!
Up 1 Down 0
Nile on May 31, 2012 at 11:57 am
This really is the gimmy generation isn't it. If an education means that much to you, then be prepared to work for it! Why should the middle class, working stiffs have to pay for your education? Go and get 2 jobs for the summer and don't blow all of your cash on booze and drugs while you live it up in the dorms. If your education is actually worth something to you, you will be prepared to work for it.
Up 1 Down 0
yukonlinda on May 31, 2012 at 9:09 am
I understand people protesting Quebec's Bill 78, but you have to be kidding me about standing in solidarity with their tuition protest! Why don't you go up to Yukon College and protest their tuition increases? Students up there are paying a heck of a lot more than those spoiled Quebec kids!
Up 1 Down 0
Jackie Ward on May 31, 2012 at 9:03 am
Seriously pathetic. Why don't you march against the conservative goverment that is destroying Canada? Where are you guys on issues that affect us all and future generations. Paying $300 more in tuition and they shut down Montreal day after day? Sad. What's even sadder is people up here protesting about something that affects no one up here. Again, pathetic.
Up 1 Down 0
Build a bridge back to Quebec on May 31, 2012 at 8:56 am
This is where this protest belongs
Up 1 Down 0
Build a bridge on May 31, 2012 at 7:40 am
As a university student that attends a school not in Quebec I think this is ridiculous. Quebec already has the lowest tuition in the country, so maybe if these students are going to complain about tuition increases in Quebec then they should go to a different university in Canada where tuition alone is over 7000 a year. I do understand the student debt is a big issue, but all the government is doing is trying to put these schools on par with what every other student in Canada is paying.
Up 1 Down 1
Owen Williams on May 31, 2012 at 7:32 am
Thank you Max & Vince for covering the story.