Yukon North Of Ordinary

News archive for February 12, 2010

RCMP investigating paramedic’s allegations

A complaint made by a paramedic who allegedly saw an RCMP officer choke a restrained man into unconsciousness is being investigated by local police, an RCMP spokesman said today.

By Justine Davidson on February 12, 2010 at 5:16 pm

photo

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Sgt. Don Rogers

A complaint made by a paramedic who allegedly saw an RCMP officer choke a restrained man into unconsciousness is being investigated by local police, an RCMP spokesman said today.

Sgt. Don Rogers confirmed an offical complaint was lodged with the Commission for Public Complaints Against the RCMP regarding an incident which occurred in October 2008.

The compaint was filed almost a year later, in September 2009.

According to a story published today on the independent news site Rabble.ca, paramedic Sasha Podolchak filed the complaint after allegedly witnessing a corporal with the Whitehorse RCMP assault a prisoner.

The complaint alleges that Podolchak and another paramedic were called to RCMP cells to attend to a man with a self-inflicted head wound.

When they arrived, the man was being restrained by police. His hands and feet were bound and his mouth covered with a spit guard, according to the report on Rabble.ca, but when the paramedics asked if they could enter the cell to check on the man, they were told to wait.

The man’s mouth began to fill with blood from the head wound, the report states.

Quoting from Podolchak’s one-page complaint, Rabble.ca reported:

“He made an effort to clear the blood from his own mouth under the spit hood by spitting the blood toward his lap area.

“The corporal then forced the patient’s head back with both his hands around the patient’s neck and throat area.

“The patient resisted this, trying to push his head forward. All the while, I witnessed the corporal pushing hard on the patient’s throat and neck. There were other constables standing around watching this whole incident unfold.”

Podolchak alleges the choking continued until the man lost consciousness.

According to the Rabble.ca report, Podolchak was so upset by the incident, she had to leave the scene before attending to the man.

“It’s under investigation like any other investigation, criminal or not, done by the RCMP,” Rogers said of the complaint.

He added that “an experienced investigator of a rank higher than the person being investigated is given the file and we work to ensure that we do a thorough and fair investigation.”

Rogers could not confirm the name of the officer or officers who are the subject of the complaint. He did say the officer named in the file is no longer working in the Yukon.

“The investigation is still ongoing,” he said.

As in any criminal probe, it will be up to the lead investigating officer to decide if criminal charges will be laid.

So far, no formal charges resembling the ones made in Podolchak’s complaint have been laid against the corporal in the Yukon courts.

Apart from facing criminal charges, police officers found guilty of misconduct may also be disciplined internally.

Rogers said that to his knowledge, the corporal has not been taken off duty because of the complaint.

While this file is being investigated by the accused’s own colleagues, the RCMP changed their policy on police-on-police investigations just last week.

From now on, the Mounties will call in officers from Outside police forces – the Vancouver Police Department or the Edmonton Police Service, for example – to conduct investigations of their members when complaints are made.

“The RCMP would prefer to never investigate its own employees and has always supported having outside agencies conduct such investigations,” reads a statement posted on the RCMP website Feb. 4.

“... Canadians are telling us they want the investigating agency assigned to conduct this sort of investigation to be independent from the police force that is the subject of the investigation.”

CommentsAdd a comment

anonymous

Feb 12, 2010 at 10:59 pm

If it bothered you so much why did you wait a year?

john

Feb 13, 2010 at 1:41 am

you hear all these stories from former inmates at the rcmp cells or wcc about the abuse they endure while in custody… I would rather police services like the edmonton provincial police or another agency to step in, not have it within the rcmp

I would also like to see the rcmp have random stress/pychological testing done.

the few bad bullies the force has, gives the rest of the rcmp bad names.

soldierpiper

Feb 13, 2010 at 12:11 pm

The RCMP do a excellent job ,I doubt that this happened.To the untrained eye it may have looked different then it actually was.Come on all those mounties would not just stand around watching a cuffed man get chocked out.

barry ridley

Feb 14, 2010 at 11:55 am

how wonderful it must be to be able to assualt an restrained person , not get charged , keep your job , and get re-assigned to somewhere else ( out of sight , out of mind)RCMP have no honor or integrity left, keep it up guy’s stick together and get your storie’s all staight…. you digust us.

mosi

Feb 15, 2010 at 7:05 am

No matter what the allegations/circumstances are, you CANT
have ANY police force investigate itself. It just does not work. Too much conflict of interest and risk of favourtism at stake. Same with the Stonechild Inquiry/case in Saskatoon when the Saskatoon Police Investigated itself and found in their favour.

Terry Anderson

Feb 16, 2010 at 12:34 am

Just as always.  Its under investigation is another way of saying this.  Shut up and leave us alone.  We do what we want and there is nothing you can do about it.  We are the law and therefore we do what we want when we want.  Don’t raise trouble for us or we will rasie trouble for you.  Does this sound familiar?  Of course the response to this article will be either I go to jail for a trumped up charge or they will have a total denial of the charges or it will take 5 years to complete the investigation or the officer is no longer with the force or some lame garbage that we seem to always hear.  A good example is the RCMP officer in Vancouver charged with hit and run while being drunk.  He is back on duty getting paid and he killed a man.  If that was the normal citizen you would still be in jail.  I am so sick of this two tiered justice system.  I beleive that the police should be held to a higher standard.  They say they are and I say it is all just empty words to appease the population.  When will there be a non judicial system that is not in any way involved in police matters or politics that have the authority and power to remove a bad officer.  When will they say that the panel has the right to immeditely suspend a officer that has apparently violated the law and suspend them.  And I don’t mean with pay.  That’s garbage.  Get rid of the police union as it is the citizens that pay the wages of these officers and not the union.  Yes, I agree with the union to represent the officers, but this is to protect them from unjust treatment from there employer.  Not as a tool to use in a public investigation of wrong doing.
When are the citizens of this great country going to say enough is enough?  It is a sad day indeed when the police are above the law of this civilized nation.

damien lankow

Feb 16, 2010 at 9:10 pm

soldierpiper you are completely blind and have no clue what actually happens behind closed doors. its worse than you think

northerngal

Feb 16, 2010 at 9:18 pm

well shows how sheepish the yukon rcmp and througout canada can be!!! investigation going on should have no problems arn’t all cells around the yk have camara’s in each cell??oh yah knowing them they probably would have destroyed the tape or came up with so bogus story to go along with that!!!

D G

Feb 16, 2010 at 10:16 pm

The police are the same as the rest of us, nobody is above the law. This is an extremely embarrassing incident for the RCMP, I have the utmost respect that the RCMP will do a commendable job and give the officer in question whatever he deserves. Investigating things such as assault is the job of the police, if I were an officer I would want this matter dealt with properly. Unfortunately those who believe that the RCMP cannot do there job should leave well enough alone or join the RCMP and straighten things out themselves.

LM

Feb 17, 2010 at 5:59 pm

Not only did one RCMP member give the rest of the force a bad reputation, the Whitehorse correctional centre were people are detained until proven innocent isn’t fit for human beings. Even if they are innocent…they are treated horribly.  Cramped sleeping arrangments and are practically starved.  Maybe some of your “respected” law enforcers and MPs should have to spend a weekend or more there. These horrible conditions create tension and anger…creating a worse situation for a person waiting to be released.  What ever happened to innocent until proven guilty.

soldierpiper

Feb 18, 2010 at 6:49 am

For damien lankow ,like one other reader said ,Why did it take a year to complain??to have other mounties just stand near & not stop this abuse by one of their own makes no sense.That would imply that the whole group of them are no good.Every RCMP I have ever known has always been very friendly & law abiding .No way would they just stand & not stop it if it really happened.It has no truth to it in my mind,the RCMP have the highest of standards.

damien lankow

Feb 18, 2010 at 8:30 pm

maybe thats because you havent been on the other side of the law. it says in the atricle one officer did try to stop it. and from what ive seen a lot of them are no good. you have no idea

LM

Feb 18, 2010 at 11:04 pm

“Why did it take a year to complain?”...maybe she could only live with the guilt of knowing what happened and not doing anything about it for a year. Could be any reason, the fact that the officer(s) in question left the Yukon says something happened. People in power can learn to abuse there power…they are only human.It only takes a couple bad apples. Abuse can come in many forms.  One for instance would be only having a drinking supply of water from one dirty sink next to two toiletts in a 10x10 room for up to 20 men at a time. Thats what the men at the WCC have to endure. I can’t see that passing any health regulations.  To live with that for any length of time is abuse from the inside out. That shouldn’t be legal.

francias pillman

Feb 19, 2010 at 3:42 pm

Fire them all and replace them with the Canadian Rangers.

anonymous

Feb 19, 2010 at 6:09 pm

For LM
The Yukon is a stepping stone for most RCMP thats why we have such a high turn over rate. and as their conditions of living are concerned - Don’t do the crime if you Don’t want to do the time - why should they get better living conditions than alot of Yukoners who don’t do criminal activity?

soldierpiper

Feb 20, 2010 at 8:09 am

After reading the CBC news I admit I could be wrong about the RCMP.If this did happen then all the mounties that just watched it should be fired off the force along with the cpl who did it.We do not need a Gestapo mentality in any police force.What a disgrace to all the good cops that go out everyday & uphold the law with integrity.

D G

Feb 21, 2010 at 9:35 pm

If you really want to bring the Whitehorse correctional center into the equation. Tell those fools that get themselves in trouble to stay out of trouble. Why should services be provided for people that will not obey the law. Cold meals and a wooden board is all those people should receive. Make something of yourself and you will become entitled to these services because you can pay for them yourself not live off the justice system. I have to work and make a living to support my family and provide the services that these men and women seem to expect for free.

Add a comment

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your full name and email address are required before your comment will be posted.

Commenting is not available in this section entry.

Comment preview