Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Vince Fedoroff

THE FORMAL VOTE – Whitehorse city council votes unanimously Monday evening on a motion moved by Coun. Kirk Cameron to request the removal of Community Services Minister Brad Cathers from his portfolio. Council is also urging Premier Darrell Pasloski to shuffle Cathers out of the Yukon Housing Corp. Portfolio. Inset Brad Cathers

‘We feel shaken to the core,’ Curtis says

Whitehorse city council is calling for the removal of cabinet minister Brad Cathers from his role as minister of Community Services and minister responsible for the Yukon Housing Corp.

By Stephanie Waddell on October 28, 2014

Whitehorse city council is calling for the removal of cabinet minister Brad Cathers from his role as minister of Community Services and minister responsible for the Yukon Housing Corp.

An unprecedented resolution passed unanimously by council Monday evening calls on Premier Darrell Pasloski to move Cathers from his two portfolios.

It asks that he “instruct a replacement to take immediate action to design and fund programs for affordable housing targeted to help workers who cannot find affordable housing, especially those in the service industry and resource sector of Whitehorse.”

“I feel this minister has failed miserably,” Mayor Dan Curtis said after voting with the rest of council in the hopes of seeing the minister “shuffled” to a portfolio that may better suit his skills.

Cathers has broken protocol on a number of occasions, the mayor argued. He has shown he doesn’t respect the municipal level of government, Curtis added.

Neither Cathers nor Pasloski returned calls from the Star this morning.

The 1 1/2 page resolution, prepared prior to the meeting and presented by Coun. Kirk Cameron, is something all five council members present said they were not taking lightly, and offered their full support on.

Councillors John Streicker and Betty Irwin were absent from the meeting.

There are a number of issues leading to the decision to call for Cathers’ dismissal, the mayor said, though housing was a major highlight of the resolution.

Part of it states: “... the Minister of Yukon Housing cancelled the affordable housing projects under the Northern Housing Trust after meeting with a small group of constituents yet without considering the larger interests and needs of all citizens of this great city; and

“Whereas Yukon Government still holds over $8 million from the Northern Housing Trust and, in addition, has signed a new Affordable Housing Agreement with the federal government that provides $1.575 million per year for the next five years to address affordable housing shortages faced in Yukon communities...”

Funding from the Northern Housing Trust was set to be used for the building of three affordable housing projects along with two rural housing projects.

While the rural initiatives remain set to go ahead, the government cancelled the Whitehorse projects last June. It cited an increase in land availability as well as the housing supply, arguing the initiative could negatively impact the market.

A number of local realtors had argued the projects could discourage private development by subsidizing new rental units. They were supported by the territory’s landlords’ association.

The government’s move to cancel the projects was met with opposition by the city and a number of local organizations, which have argued affordable housing options continue to be needed in the city.

As it was stated in last night’s resolution: “... the Association of Yukon Communities (AYC) passed two resolutions at their board meeting in September 2014 that called for the Yukon Minister to share the government’s action plan with all municipalities, to listen to the concerns of all communities, and then to act on the shortages of affordable housing, an issue faced by a significant number of Yukon communities.”

While Cathers was at the September AYC board meeting in Faro, Curtis argued the minister was there simply to state the decision of government to cancel the projects was final, and to “stay tuned” for further announcements from the government.

“That kind of relationship is not a very good one,” the mayor told reporters after last night’s council meeting.

He continually stressed his “exasperation” in dealing with the current minister and his hope that the city would be viewed as a partner and given the respect another government should get.

He argued the previous Community Services minister – Elaine Taylor – had a more co-operative relationship with municipalities, following up on issues.

Taylor was moved out of the role in August 2013 during a cabinet shuffle.

While she became Education minister and held on to other portfolios, Cathers was shuffled from Energy, Mines and Resources into Community Services, along with becoming the minister responsible for the housing corporation, the Yukon Liquor Corp. and the Yukon Lottery Commission.

Since then, it’s become difficult to meet with and work with the minister, the mayor said.

“It’s been a very difficult and trying time. We feel shaken to the core,” Curtis said.

The last part of the resolution notes the impact on the relationship with the city stating: “.... the Minister of Community Services has time and time again failed to engage with us, the City of Whitehorse, in partnership, mutual respect and trust, thus failing to demonstrate his willingness to set municipal issues at the forefront of the matters important to him in fulfilling his responsibilities as the minister responsible for the Community Services portfolio.”

It then goes on to request the Lake Laberge MLA’s removal from his role in Community Services and the housing corporation.

“I completely support this resolution,” Coun. Jocelyn Curteanu stated after Cameron presented it.

As “of late,” she pointed out, there’s been a lack of timely information coming from the Yukon government to the city.

Similarly, Coun. Dave Stockdale pointed out the city is home to 70 per cent of the territory’s population, and the Yukon government needs to work with the city.

“We need a better partnership with the Yukon government,” Stockdale said, adding he hopes the resolution will get “us to the table.”

Affordable housing has been the “no. 1 priority” for this council, and it’s clearly needed in the city, Coun. Mike Gladish said in voicing his support for the resolution.

While good efforts have been made to address social housing, affordable housing remains an urgent need in the city.

As Curtis said, the city is continually contacted by employers about what is being done to address the high cost of housing in the city to draw potential employees to the region.

Curtis noted the resolution “will not come as a surprise” to the government, given the concerns the city has already tried to express.

Questioned about what last night’s resolution will mean for a meeting scheduled for Friday with the Yukon government, Curtis commented that it will be “nice to clear the air.”

He noted he looks forward to working with any minister willing to work with the city.

Comments (32)

Up 4 Down 3

Wilf Carter on Nov 2, 2014 at 5:41 pm

I have written a response to Salar comments. The paper must have not got my response to your comments. Just to repeat. I thank you for your comments because you are speaking up on what you believe and I wish more would. There is no right or wrong comments but what you think. feel, experience and believe in and that is your freedom to provide your voice in a great country like Canada.
I hope the media does not filter freedom of speech that is the right of all Canadians and Yukoner's. I have known the McRobb family since mid 1980's and they have spent millions of dollars in the Yukon economy investing in a number of businesses creating jobs for people in the Yukon. The present MLA from Kluane has worked very hard to support his riding the best he can. Public life is not easy for anyone because people will take them a part not knowing the facts of what is taking place.
My motives are very simple, a better government for all. The Yukon is not getting it at the present time from any party. Basically they are all ticked off at me but don't understand where I am going with my sudden entrance into a public challenge of all the parties actions. Garbage in garbage out is one of my understanding of Yukon politics. Thanks Salar for making your views known keep speaking up!

Up 3 Down 5

Wilf Carter on Nov 2, 2014 at 11:40 am

Good one Salar! My interest in political life is to clean up the messes in parts of the Yukon Government that are harming the employees and get back to good governance for all the people. Interesting how you bring up Gary M. I have known him and his family going back to the mid 1980's and they have contributed a great deal to the Yukon Economy from their many years of investing in the Yukon in Northwest Moving and Storage, owning apartment buildings and other investments. So Gary and his family are net contributors to the Yukon for a lot of years. McRobb has paid millions of dollars into the Yukon economy. Wade is doing his best for his riding people so maybe you should run for office and see how easy it is to sit in office and have all the solutions to everything that voters want and expect. Public life is not easy for anyone in any party. Thanks for your comments at least you are prepared to speak up and state what you think. I wish more would.

Up 19 Down 6

Salar on Nov 1, 2014 at 8:19 am

Wilf Carter.....yes you selflessly want to enter politics.....because the Yukon could be self sustaining......even without any way to utilize the rest of the world (no links in transportation....we're way up here for one).
You sound as naïve as Gary McRobb....he got his pension after doing virtually nothing....interesting how Ischenko is repeating history.....wonder if he'll get his pension?

Up 14 Down 13

Wilf Carter on Oct 30, 2014 at 10:39 pm

Yukon56 Thank you! I have a lot of experience that gives me some perspective on what the Yukon might consider. I am not saying I am right but just trying to get some idea's on debate that effect the Yukon interest. Yes, I plan on running for political life but I am not committed to any party other than the Yukon people and their interest.
My kids were born in the Yukon and I love the Yukon and I want it to be successful, for all of us. We will all have our own view on what we believe the Yukon should be. Thank you for questioning my motives. My motives are very clear to develop the interest of the Yukon in a manner that supports our kids, seniors, environment, business, future in a manner that creates the strongest economy in Canada. I want the Yukon to be self sufficient and not depend on Canadian hand outs. As an individual to have the opportunity to work for and with First Nations in the Yukon and been involved with land claims in the 1900's and again in 2007, I appreciate the opportunity to be part of the success of the Yukon going into the future. It is not easy but we as Yukoner's are trail makers in Canada's future and will create a future of a new nation over the next 50 years. You have to believe in yourself and what we can do to make a Yukon in Canada. Politically I have never had any interest in any party other than what is right for our society and people.

Up 21 Down 2

yukon56 on Oct 30, 2014 at 4:17 pm

Wilf seems to be setting up for a run at something

Up 17 Down 8

TATER on Oct 30, 2014 at 4:05 pm

GO DALLAS! Your right on. Its the average taxpayer that has to cough up the tax dollars to support this cause.
And I don't see any of the "Government has to supply housing" folk running down to the bank to borrow money to build anything. They want properties built as long as they don't have to contribute.

Up 19 Down 16

Wilf Carter on Oct 30, 2014 at 3:01 pm

Liberal leader does not have any knowledge of housing or the Northern Housing Trust funds purpose. The leader stated in the house today that the Northern Housing Trust fund is for Affordable housing which is not true at all. I was on the committee on the Northern housing trust. The leader talked about social and affordable housing as two different topics.
That is not correct! Any public funds invested into housing is social housing. How can voters, vote for elected officials that don't understand or have knowledge in housing? I do not have confidence in any elected official that does not understand the subject matter and tries to talk about the subject like the Mayor of Whitehorse. Get some research done before you speak in public so there is some credit-ability please. Thanks What a waste of tax payers dollars.

Up 12 Down 5

bobbybitman on Oct 30, 2014 at 1:27 pm

Thumbs up/down is not working again. I gave three comments a thumbs up, and as it recorded the thumbs up, the program you use simultaneously gave them a thumbs down. Three comments in a row.

Up 39 Down 13

Charles on Oct 29, 2014 at 10:45 pm

Shake away Dan & Co. Maybe they could consider getting their own house in order first. Quit raising our COW fees while throwing $$ away on friviolity. Most residents would not argue if increases went to worthwhile projects such as housing, but for these folk to condemn a higher gov while they themselves have poured $$ into Sima, bike lanes etc. is a bad case of ill fitting Hallowe'en costumes. If I didn't know the date I would have thought it April 1. Mind your own business Mayor & Council; allow the electorate to decide who they are dissatisfied with, and note that may include all of you. We all have MLAs who we can contact to complain. I don't remember appointing COW as my agent to do that for me!

Up 24 Down 18

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 10:32 pm

I can't wait for the next election in the Yukon and all the actions of the liberals and NDP are replayed for Yukoners on where these parties are going, how they operate, what they believe in for the Yukon, there misguided understanding of governing and lack of respect for voters interest.

Up 33 Down 10

north_of_60 on Oct 29, 2014 at 6:35 pm

Both the YTG and CoW governments have demonstrated their ongoing incompetency on the housing issue, however for either to criticize the other is the pot calling the kettle black.
I agree with the comments criticizing the Mayor and Council for political meddling.

Up 19 Down 29

Hmmm on Oct 29, 2014 at 6:15 pm

The silent majority agree with this move.

Up 21 Down 17

Yukoner 3 on Oct 29, 2014 at 5:00 pm

The refusal by YTG to do anything about the affordable housing/rental issue is shameful. The federal government gave the territory money SPECIFICALLY for this issue! But Cathers said 'no, we don't want reduced rents because it will hurt the landlords who struggle to get by'. People who think this is not appropriate should tell Pasloski and Cathers, there is contact info on the YTG website. Minister Taylor would not have allowed relations to sour this much.

Up 27 Down 18

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 4:35 pm

I bet you are more shaken to the core now after the response.

Up 33 Down 21

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 4:25 pm

By the comments Kirk and Dan you guys have made a major tactical error and Sandy you have to wear it along with every other liberal.

Up 36 Down 11

J White on Oct 29, 2014 at 4:03 pm

This motion by city council is not productive, and will not result in anything good for the people of Whitehorse. People who think this public feuding is not appropriate should tell mayor and council. There's a contact link on the City website.

Up 22 Down 24

Fred Statham on Oct 29, 2014 at 2:24 pm

Desperate times call for desperate measures. It is hard to believe that Affordable Housing was the #2 Issue in the 2011 Territorial Election, and that we are still trying to find solutions to this problem.

This is a partisan measure, but nothing else seems to get through to The Pasloski Government. This is a very frustrating situation that needs a lot of collaboration and consultation to solve.

It is disappointing to see Whitehorse Mayor and Council take this step, but what else can be done; set up a tent city on the lawn of the legislature AGAIN?

Sincerely, Fred Statham.

Up 33 Down 18

Wilf Carter on Oct 29, 2014 at 11:23 am

Municipal Education 101 stay out using your power for political reasons because every municipal Mayor and Councillors that have done that in Canada have got their a-s kicked by voters who see these actions as only stunt for political interest. Municipal education 202 get the COW financial house in order. H aving a $3.3 million dollar deficit is poor fiscal management. Can you image if either of these two, If they became Minister of Housing, how would they spend the housing funds? Municipal Education 204 Dave I have known you for 25 years in municipal government and you support conflict between governments. That is not any municipal governments role and you know it. "Disappointment"! Municipal education 302 where is the COW policy on public housing for the COW? Where is the COW municipal funds to match the housing trust money like most Cities in Canada do when they get into public housing. Municipal education 380 who on COW council has experience or education in public housing? Municipal Education 440 the Yukon Government should take 80% of the remaining funds of the Yukon Trust and give it out by per capita to the municipalities and let them invest it. COW would get most of it. Municipal education 480 then the COW can show what they can do! Municipal education 490 so Kirk and Dan you are going to run in the next election or are you just trying to help the liberals? Anyway Sandy this is danger strategy if the voters are going to buy this we will have to see. Municipal education 555 so two Councillors did not vote on the motion that means the COW was divided on this action.
Finally municipal graduation school education for COW mayor and Councillors, who voted on this motion. Municipal education 600 what do you hope to gain by this action? Municipal education 602 where are you going with this action? Municipal education 604 how is this going to solve a housing situation which is already correcting itself like a private sector market does. Do you agree COW? Municipal education 606 so the COW want to get into the housing business and hurt the 100's of people out there that have developed and are planning on developing rental units in effect stopping the private sector rental housing market in the COW. Municipal education 700 the COW here-by gives notice that they are planning on getting into the private sector housing market in the COW and want to get into the housing business without any public policy or sense of direction in housing. Municipal education 800 I request the people of the COW to request a recall of the Mayor Curtis and Councillor Cameron by promoting their poor fiscal management of tax payers millions of dollars being wasted! Municipal education 900 Mayor and Councillors are not fulfilling the mandate the voters voted you in for and your action only serves frustrated voters in COW more?
By the way you all failed that voted for this motion and I will send you your failure in municipal government education. I have twenty years in housing as I stated before working for Housing Commissions, First Nations, with Yukon Housing in the public sector. I the private sector, have experience in public housing and all types of different housing programs. Just for the liberals and NDP who seem to think they have the answers to the COW housing needs there is no such thing as affordable housing but public housing that is social. Any public funds invested in a public housing under a public housing policy is social. How hard is it to understand the facts and stop misleading voters.

Up 41 Down 0

Wundering on Oct 29, 2014 at 7:59 am

While this gives the appearance of being more politically motivated than out of genuine concern to get a functioning program in place to address this issue.
There seems to be a total failure by the Yukon government and the City to address this issue in a constructive manner that tries to meet the needs and concerns of all Yukoners. The Feds appear to have stepped up to the plate with funding, so what is the problem with our local politicians, both territorially and municipally?

Up 62 Down 17

Tater on Oct 28, 2014 at 11:45 pm

Hmmmm, This is the City Council that spends a million bucks so bike riders don't have to walk their bikes across the bridge from and to Riverdale. Maybe they should have used some of that cash to support housing.

Up 28 Down 23

Moose on Oct 28, 2014 at 8:26 pm

Seriously Brice? Do you also believe that the Liberal Party forced all Councillors, the Chamber of Commerce, Anti-Poverty Coalition, and others to go against Cathers? Affordable rental/housing is a problem whether you admit or not. Cathers is doing what his riding association tells him to do which is to protect the landlords. Why is it up to the less fortunate to pay off the mortgage of people who are buying houses they couldn't otherwise afford? They are inflating the market by doing so and making it harder for others to break into the market at all. I don't buy the crocodile tears and neither should you.

Up 40 Down 18

Wilf Carter on Oct 28, 2014 at 7:34 pm

So Kirk and Dan what experience do you have in public housing policy/none? What experience do you have in political future of housing, none. What experience do you understand in the future of housing in the Yukon given the history of the Yukon. Why don't you both solve the over budget problems of the COW budget $3.3 dollar budget that you supported creating a tax increase of 12%. and other tax increases that the people of the COW are tired of! Great liberal tax increasers as you are known for. Show me your money Kirk because you know whom I am. See you at the next party!
The COW is in trouble because they want to use their political position to fight the Yukon Government. Dan and Kirk accept the fact you lost to the Yukon Party for the good of the Yukon. So what is your direction going forward on housing or anything because I was in the house today and liberals like to talk about garbage, nothing like the economy or jobs for our students.
Sandy Silver, our person from education, has not brought up how our children can afford an education. Kirk and Sandy get in touch with what is important in education for our children and how they can pay for it. The liberal or the NDP have no plan how to support the education of our Yukon children. There is no direction for the Yukon future. What is the direction for the Yukon by the Liberal or NDP party.

Up 51 Down 9

Dallas Schaber on Oct 28, 2014 at 7:16 pm

Mayor Curtis what are you gonna do for the rest of the people that work two or three jobs, work away from home and family, sacrificing family life and weekends, etc., to make mortgage payments????? Are you gonna cut them a hell of a deal in property taxes????? Are you gonna cut the affordable housing recipients a hell of a deal on their property taxes?????? Awaiting your response!

Up 53 Down 23

Krysta Meekins on Oct 28, 2014 at 7:10 pm

This is an inappropriate and apparently partisan motion coming from the Whitehorse mayor and council. Very disappointing.

Up 31 Down 13

BnR on Oct 28, 2014 at 6:34 pm

Brice, it was a call against Brad Cathers, period. The mayor called for anyone but Brad. This would never have happened with Elaine Taylor as the minister for community services.

Up 53 Down 11

"shaken to the core"? Seriously? on Oct 28, 2014 at 6:11 pm

So let's get a bunch of people together and draft a resolution about how disappointed we are with mayor and council - difficult to work with, disrespectful of citizens' wishes, doesn't listen, etc etc and present it at Council meeting.

Up 49 Down 5

June Jackson on Oct 28, 2014 at 6:04 pm

As any reader knows, I am a proponent of low cost housing. But, NOT the way government is planning to do it... filling the bank accounts of their contractor friends... I think the Council is out of their mandate to be poking their noses into housing. They have contractor pals too?

Housing is a number 1 priority? Shaken to the core? A gunman in the hallway is shaken to the core, a number 1 priority would be maintaining the City on the money its got instead of being 600K in the hole and raising taxes and cost of services... priorities might be why so many people are leaving the territory. If Council is 'shaken to the core' then they have too much time on their hands and should cut back their pay and cut down their hours. Garden or something. Or, if they want to stick their noses in government business they could petition the government to leave the seniors programs alone. Should this government proceed with the recommendations in the Yukon Health Care Review of 2009 an awful lot of seniors will be in need, are they just starting the cuts with the Pioneer Grant?

In any case, the Council does not sound very cooperative..'we'll work with anyone willing to work with the city".. but that only sounds like that will happen if everyone else agrees with them.

Up 54 Down 14

Politics at its lowest on Oct 28, 2014 at 5:37 pm

Does anyone think Premier Pasloski will remove Minister Cathers now, and risk being perceived as bowing to pressure? It's simply not right that one level of government should criticize another like this - should be discussed and resolved privately, not as a city council resolution. And be careful, Mayor Curtis - maybe some minister or deputy minister could start listing all of your shortfalls and present a bill in the legislature for YOUR removal.

Up 21 Down 20

Carruthers on Oct 28, 2014 at 5:27 pm

Brice you seem like a pretty bright guy you could be a engineer, just kidding. You are aware that the Mayor asked the Premier to swap Brad out a year ago? Anyway why don't you run for Municipal politics, oh yeah you already did.

Up 41 Down 8

Mark Smith on Oct 28, 2014 at 4:55 pm

Sure hope this is not about giving away millions of dollars to a few developers who were planning to build housing units beyond the finanial reach of our lower income residents.

Up 46 Down 43

m on Oct 28, 2014 at 4:30 pm

"As Curtis said, the city is continually contacted by employers about what is being done to address the high cost of housing in the city to draw potential employees to the region."

That's a good one coming from a mayor who wants to fire a territorial minister while accusing him of listening to a small number of constituents.

Up 84 Down 60

Brice Carruthers on Oct 28, 2014 at 4:00 pm

Kirk Cameron and Dan Curtis, both former candidates for the Yukon Liberal Party, push a motion against Brad Cathers one day after Sandy Silver calls for Brad Cathers' resignation in the house. Council should not be used for Liberal Party electioneering. This is a disgraceful move by a body that is supposed to be apolitical.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.