Whitehorse Daily Star

National Aboriginal Day appropriate day to apologize for residential schools: Chief

The chief of the Kwanlin Dün First Nation says National Aboriginal Day on Tuesday would be an appropriate time for the premier to make a formal apology on behalf of the Yukon government for the brutalities experienced by generations of Yukon residential school students, their families and communities.

By Sidney Cohen on June 20, 2016

The chief of the Kwanlin Dün First Nation says National Aboriginal Day on Tuesday would be an appropriate time for the premier to make a formal apology on behalf of the Yukon government for the brutalities experienced by generations of Yukon residential school students, their families and communities.

“I think that would be a wonderful day for the Yukon government to make an apology, but if they are going to make an apology it has to be sincere,” Chief Doris Bill said in an interview earlier this month.

Tomorrow will be the 20th National Aboriginal Day in Canada.

The day recognizes the heritage and diverse cultures of Canada’s First Nations, Inuit and Metis peoples, and is celebrated with music, food, dancing and special events across the country.

Premier Darrell Pasloski is in Vancouver today for a meeting of Canadian finance ministers (see story, p. 11), and could not be reached for comment.

The premier was going to miss National Aboriginal Day in the Yukon, but changed his plans suddenly this morning. He will now be in Whitehorse for the holiday, but it is unclear how he will participate, or if he intends to make an apology that day.

The premiers of Alberta and Ontario have issued formal apologies for provincial government policies that supported the residential school system, and government silence in the face of harm inflicted on indigenous peoples as a result of these policies.

Student deaths, as well as the physical, sexual and psychological abuse, were ubiquitous in residential schools, and residual trauma continues to be felt in indigenous communities today.

“Although the province of Alberta did not establish this system, members of this chamber did not take a stand against it,” Alberta Premier Rachel Notley said in June 2015.

“For this silence, we apologize.”

Kathleen Wynne, the premier of Ontario, delivered her apology in the provincial legislature on May 30. That was nearly one year after the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) released a summary of it’s report on the residential school system, and its 94 Calls to Action to redress the harm and begin to heal as a country.

“I apologize for the province’s silence in the face of abuses and deaths at residential schools. And I apologize for the fact that the residential schools are only one example of systemic, intergenerational injustices inflicted upon indigenous communities throughout Canada,” said Wynne.

“The act of apology is not the end, nor is it the beginning. It is but one step on the journey to reconciliation and healing that we are committed to walking together.”

Former prime minister Stephen Harper apologized for residential schools on behalf of the Canadian government and Canadians in 2008.

“To the approximately 80,000 living former students, and all family members and communities, the Government of Canada now recognizes that it was wrong to forcibly remove children from their homes and we apologize for having done this,” he said. 

“We now recognize that, far too often, these institutions gave rise to abuse or neglect and were inadequately controlled, and we apologize for failing to protect you.”

The day after Harper made his apology in 2008, Todd Hardy, the then-leader of the Yukon NDP, called on the Yukon government to make a similar gesture.

“I’m hoping that maybe this fall, we could build on this and move forward from a territorial perspective and make a very formal apology in the legislative assembly,” he told the CBC at the time.

During a sitting of the legislature in 2008, the late NDP leader urged the government to issue a formal apology for residential schools in the Yukon to Yukon First Nations.

Dennis Fentie, who was the Yukon Party premier at the time, amended Hardy’s motion so that instead of issuing its own apology, the territory would “acknowledge and fully endorse” Harper’s apology, and the legislative assembly agreed.

Pasloski has not made a formal apology on behalf of the Yukon government, but he has acknowledged the sordid legacy of residential schools in the territory.

“All Canadians have a responsibility to understand the impact of residential schools and our role in the healing process,” the premier said in a statement last June, a week after the TRC came out with its 94 Calls to Action.

“The Yukon government is committed to the ongoing work of building a healthy and optimistic future for all Yukoners.”

The TRC commissioners determined that the residential school system was a central component of the “cultural genocide” that Canada committed against its first peoples.

Residential schools intentionally sought to destroy the language, culture and indigenous identity of students, in part through removing children from their families and traditional ways of life.

There were four residential schools and two hostels for indigenous children in the Yukon, and one in northern British Columbia that was attended by Yukon First Nation students.

At these residential schools, as at residential schools across Canada, children suffered physical, sexual and psychological abuse at the hands of those who were charged with caring for them and teaching them. And there were deaths.

The TRC called the Canadian government’s apology “a necessary first step,” but reconciling with the dark history of the residential school system, and healing from it, will take much much more than words.

“The words of the apologies will ring hollow if Canada’s actions fail to produce the necessary social, cultural, political, and economic change that benefits aboriginal peoples and all Canadians,” the TRC report reads.

“Reparations for historical injustices must include not only apology, financial redress, legal reform, and policy change, but also the rewriting of national history and public commemoration.

“In every region of the country, survivors and others have sent a strong message, as received by this Commission: for reconciliation to thrive in the coming years, Canada must move from apology to action.”

Comments (14)

Up 49 Down 3

OIC on Jun 22, 2016 at 3:02 pm

I don't agree with requesting an apology for residential school on Aboriginal Day. Aboriginal should be a day to be proud to be aboriginal not a day of sadness of what RS brought to people. This needs to be kept separate.
I do agree that apologies have been made in the past and should be accepted. Of course it doesn't solve anything but accept it and move forward. Focus on healing and move forward to bettering your people.

Up 56 Down 11

cameron on Jun 21, 2016 at 8:49 pm

Enough already
Get on with your lives
How many apologies do you need? Maybe that is an excuse to never take responsibility for yourself and just get on with life.?
We cannot afford this financially anymore - most of the taxpayers who have to actually keep paying for all of this nonsense were not even alive when the Residential schools were active.
You are not the only people in the world who have had a hard time. Just thank your lucky stars you did not get born in Syria - no one would care about your complaints and no one would feed or clothe you there.

Up 59 Down 14

north_of_60 on Jun 21, 2016 at 1:59 pm

All we get from the aboriginals is an endless litany of complaints and demands. Where is the gratitude and thanks for all the benefits of technological civilization they're so happy to accept? Prior to contact with civilization their lives were nasty, brutish and short.

A lot of people were beaten and abused in the past; those were unhappy times for a lot of us. The aboriginals have no monopoly on poor treatment.

No more apologies, there's been quite enough already.
It's time to put the past in the past and to focus on building a better future together.

Up 31 Down 3

ProScience Greenie on Jun 21, 2016 at 5:31 am

From Wikipedia's Yukon entry - "Prior to 1979, the territory was administered by the commissioner who was appointed by the federal Minister of Indian Affairs and Northern Development. The commissioner had a role in appointing the territory's Executive Council, served as chair, and had a day-to-day role in governing the territory. The elected Territorial Council had a purely advisory role."

Up 1 Down 35

David E.H. Smith on Jun 21, 2016 at 12:46 am

‘YOU’ Committed, &/or, Enabled Secret 'Cultural Genocide' Against Aboriginal Canadians’, et al,
or, Was/Is it Corporate Canada’s (The Canadian Establishment’s) Secret 'Cultural Genocide' Committed Against Aboriginal Canadians’; Native Residential Schools of Canada, et al?

Pope Francis may continue to have ‘Difficulty’ Apologizing to the PM Trudeau for Residential Schools’ Abuses while PM Continues to Blame & Punish Those Who He Has Been Deliberately Deprived of the Info including the citizens of the EU? Other Religious Leaders may have similar Difficulties.

Liberals swear that they may not have had any part in the Planning, Gratification, &/or, Continuing Cover-up of The Residential Schools’ Native Canadian Cultural Genocide?
New PM Trudeau sheds Tear as Liberal Party & Canadian Establishment Caught in Complicity of Cultural Genocide?


(CAN.) At the risk of annoying Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin & the Justices of The Supreme Court of Canada while they consider the merits of:
‘The Submission’ to The SUPREME COURT of CANADA:
‘The SHAREHOLDERS & Corporations of AMERICA, Japan, the EU, Canada, the Trans Pacific nations, et al
v.
the harmless Canadian NON shareholders, both; Native & non Native, et al’
(see; Google
including
'The MERKEL (Chancellor of Germany) Letter; To Sue, or, Be Sued?'
(see; Google),

would it be more accurate if the Chief Justice said that it was corporate Canada & its associated religious & governmental leaders that attempted 'cultural genocide' on Aboriginal Canadians as opposed to saying the vague remark that is was ‘Canada’ that attempted the aforementioned 'cultural genocide'?
And, what other nations are, &/or, can be, implicated as a consequence of being co-signatories to the recent flurry of Global Treaties/'Arrangements' with Canada?
***
Prime Minister Trudeau; 'Blaming & Punishing Those Who Have Been Deliberately Deprived of the Info’; ‘Inquiry’ Settlements Protect Gratified Rapists, Pedophiles, et al. Courts Only Forum for Justice, Guilt & Reconciliation.

RECONCILIATION between:
Native & NON Native Canadians
AND
the Government of Canada & corporate Canada'.
Excerpts are from "TOWARDS A MORE INFORMED OPINION regarding the Environmental Impact& Context of the Enbridge's Northern Gateway (Pipeline) Project (NGP), et al" by DEHS. (Last Edited; Nov., 2014)

"It is also in the spirit of reconciliation between the most vulnerable Native & non-Native Canadians, et al, that ...it seems that most Canadians are insulted for being blamed for PM Trudeau (PM Harper) deliberately depriving non-Native Canadians, & the world court of public opinion...of the information...& then have the "bright idea" of blaming the good people of Alberta, et al, who have been deprived of the information...
***
FULL article, see; davidehsmith.wordpress.com
***
PLEASE CONSIDER SHARING the enclosed information & questions with 10 friends who will share it with 10 others...

Up 42 Down 8

jc on Jun 20, 2016 at 10:20 pm

Those approximately 80,000 living former students include the thousands of non-FN students as well or just the FN? I and my brothers and sisters don't recall getting an apology for being forced from our home and forcibly sent to a residential school. Nor were we ever given financial compensation.

Up 53 Down 11

jc on Jun 20, 2016 at 10:15 pm

As I mentioned before, I spent 3 years in a residential school and I didn't experience nor witness physical or sexual abuse once. Neither did my 6 brothers and sisters. But I think it would be nice if the FN would thank those who housed, fed, clothed and educated them over the years. I did. I could tell so many stories of my time there, but the Star wouldn't print them.

Up 52 Down 10

get/w/it on Jun 20, 2016 at 7:59 pm

I agree with Francis , it is time to move forward , let things rest !

Up 45 Down 8

June Jackson on Jun 20, 2016 at 7:24 pm

"The day recognizes the heritage and diverse cultures of Canada’s First Nations, Inuit and Metis peoples, and is celebrated with music, food, dancing and special events across the country." That is what the day is supposed to be... Can't even have a day of fun and celebrating... gotta ruin it.

Up 49 Down 14

drum on Jun 20, 2016 at 6:35 pm

We have done financial redress, we have done apology.
I am so glad they even remembered to mention ALL CANADIANS.
It is the rest of CANADIANS that were not even alive when the Residential Schools were active that will have to continue to pay and pay and pay and pay and the First Nations will never get past it all and just live a normal life. The rest of us do not have it perfect, who does. We get on with it and work, pay our bills and hope our children will have it easier.

Up 51 Down 16

SorrySeemsToBeTheHardestWord on Jun 20, 2016 at 5:18 pm

Sorry , sorry , sorry , sorry , sorry , sorry .... apologies ... sorry , sorry ..... .Now , can we just get on with the rest of our lives please ? ( PS - Get over it !! ) .

Up 13 Down 46

Joey Manvilly on Jun 20, 2016 at 4:33 pm

I agree that an apology would be appropriate.

Up 46 Down 12

BnR on Jun 20, 2016 at 3:57 pm

But the Yukon gov had nothing to do with the whole sordid affair.... Do I have to apologize too? While we are apologizing, will CYFN apologize for the time some FN kids beat me up in elementary school? Getting jumped by them after school one day back in grade 5 kinda messed me up.
How To Burn All Your Good Will 101.

Up 86 Down 23

Francis Pillman on Jun 20, 2016 at 3:33 pm

How many more sorries do you need? Like really? And I'm not being insensitive.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.