Whitehorse Daily Star

Inequality persists among Yukoners, report confirms

When it comes to indicators such as employment, income, and voter turnout,

By Sidney Cohen on July 27, 2017

When it comes to indicators such as employment, income, and voter turnout, the Yukon outperformed the other territories, and in some cases Canada overall, in a study of social outcomes by the Conference Board of Canada.

But within the territory, inequality persists between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people.

The Canadian economics and public policy think tank looked at a variety of indicators to evaluate equity and upward mobility in the territories, including poverty, gender and racial wage gaps, crime and suicide rates, and civic engagement.

The territories scored below the national average on poverty, crime and income distribution, but performed decently on life satisfaction, in the study called Social Outcomes in the Territories.

“When assessing outcomes in the territories, we need to consider the context that helps explain why average territorial performance is distinct from and, in many cases, lower than the provincial averages,” Adam Fiser, a senior research associate at the board, said in a statement.

“The territories’ geographic isolation, low educational attainment, differences in the availability of social services, and infrastructure gaps, all have significant effects on several of the society indicators in our report and help explain why they fall behind the Canadian average on social outcomes.”

The report does not explain in great detail what causes disparities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous peoples in the territories. Indigenous populations, it says, “face distinct historical, cultural, and socio-economic challenges, including the impacts of residential schools.”

Rather than parse the root causes, this report is meant to be a “diagnostic tool,” Fiser said in an interview this morning. In other words, it can be used to pin-point areas in need of improvement.

The Yukon had among the lowest unemployment rates in Canada in 2016 at 5.6 per cent, according to the report. The national rate was seven per cent.

Still, unemployment rates “differ substantially” between Indigenous and non-Indigeous people in the Yukon.

The unemployment rate for Indigenous people with a high school diploma was 17.3 per cent, according to 2011 data used for the report.

For non-Indigenous people with the same level of education, the rate was 7.4 per cent.

The report also found vast income disparities between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Yukoners.

While 32 per cent of Yukon residents placed in the top two (out of 10) Statistics Canada income brackets, 25 per cent of Indigenous residents are in the bottom two income brackets.

“Some research associates these differences with how prepared remote Indigenous workers versus urban non-Indigenous workers are in navigating wage economy demands,” reads the report.

“In contrast, other research points to the need for employers to be more understanding and tailor their human resource strategies to the different perspectives and needs of remote Indigenous workers.”

The report found that Indigenous men in the Yukon earned 38.7 per cent less than non-Indigenous men.

Indigenous men with a university degree, however, earned 24.6 per cent more than non-Indigenous men with the same credentials.

The wage gap is wide, but education can help narrow it.

Mary Simon is the Indigenous and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC) minister’s special representative for Arctic Leadership.

In her 2017 report on the arctic for INAC, Simon notes that job opportunities for recent high school and university graduates are increasingly scarce in the South. This is not the case in the North, she said.

The jobs are there, but what is needed are qualified people to take those jobs.

“It has been barely a generation since residential school survivors took the brave and bold step of talking openly about the residential school era, dog slaughters, forced relocations and the subsequent abuse,” says Simon.

Education in the territories must be cognizant of this history and the healing currently underway. It must be “culturally relevant, adaptive and flexible,” she writes.

A university North of 60 could make a big difference for young people in the territories, said Fiser.

He said now is the time for the territorial governments to work together and with their federal and Indigenous counterparts to work out what a pan-territorial university could look like and how it might enhance the qualifications and expertise of young people in the North.

The Yukon Liberals have pledged to transition Yukon College into a university, but have yet to take significant steps toward that aim.

Closing gaps between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Yukoners will take time and a concerted effort on behalf of governments and educational institutions to build up trust that was broken, in part, by the residential school system, said Fiser.

He added that expanding access to fast Internet would also expand education opportunities in northern communities.

There are innovative ideas brewing in the North, said Fiser.

“For the federal government, it’s really important for them to continue to listen, (and) really create meaningful opportunities where folks in the territories can share their ideas,” he said.

“Geography’s not going to go away, healing takes a long time, so the federal government has to be there as a partner for the territories and for the Indigenous governments in the territories to ensure that it’s listening and can make a strategic contribution at the right time.”

Comments (11)

Up 17 Down 7

mary laker on Jul 31, 2017 at 6:35 pm

I wonder how many of those aboriginal men with university degrees, earning 24% more than white men with university degrees, actually grew up in 'white' families. Then took spots intended for aboriginal people who really faced challenges growing up, and/or spots intended to represent aboriginal people who are living a 'disadvantaged' life.

I put that in quotation marks because I think there are so many pluses to living among your extended family in the communities. It's not all bad, that is for sure.

Up 29 Down 5

Groucho d'North on Jul 31, 2017 at 10:53 am

I submit that in the main, most marginalised groups do not want to be equal to everybody else. How else would they justify special treatments and programs from government and politicians seeking to befriend voters for the next election?
If we were all equal, comparisons could be made regarding abilities and who could really be self-sufficient as a citizen, and who needs some additional help...for whatever reason they dream up?

Up 32 Down 5

ProScience Greenie on Jul 30, 2017 at 6:50 pm

Yukon College is not a place for smart people. With few exceptions it is a factory giving out meaningless degrees only good for further bloating the various levels of goverment. A N60 university will be much worse.

Young people - the world is your oyster, get out there and follow your dreams and passions. Don't let anyone hold you back or shame you for it. You can always come back home if you want and if not the world will be a better place with Yukoners out there sharing what makes us special.
INAC, could you folks just go away once and for all please.

Up 43 Down 6

Just Say'in on Jul 29, 2017 at 2:13 pm

The biggest problem with FN unemployment and lack of opportunity, is where they live. Most of the small towns and villages in the Yukon have no reason to exist and wouldn't, if not for the money being poured in by the federal government.

I hold the FN's and their policies solely responsible for this. They discourage their people from advancement at fear of loosing them from their Head Count. This Head Count is what determines the size of the cheque from the Feds.

Not until the young people see that there is no future in a community, that has no economic opportunities, then nothing will change. Full Stop.

Up 40 Down 7

JC on Jul 28, 2017 at 6:37 pm

political: Yes, I do. 76 years of living beside them. And how dare you accuse me of racism. I have a right to my beliefs and opinion. I paid for it for the last 61 years. Figure that one out. Yes I have worked and paid taxes since I was 16 and still was able to squeeze in 5 years of military service to my country. That makes me a proud Veteran and tax payer. And just in case you missed my comment some months ago, I and my 6 siblings spent several years in a Residential school. And again, I can confess with truth and honesty didn't see any physical or sexual abuse during that time even among the hundreds of aboriginal residents. And one more thing, during my life, I was able to earn 2 college degrees - at my own expense I might add. So, again, be careful with your racist accusations. Most people who make false charges are usually guilty of them, themselves.

Up 7 Down 33

Politico on Jul 28, 2017 at 3:24 pm

@jc Do you have any proof for your racist conclusions or is this one of those Trumpeter if I say it it must be true?

Up 34 Down 10

Josey Wales on Jul 28, 2017 at 1:28 am

I am glad they are bringing these inequalities to light.
Example, if convicted of equally appalling violent crimes...as a melanoma challenged Canadian I get no "outta jail free" card., no culture camp, no historical enabling...just time.
Section 718.2(e) of our criminal code cares not of me....
Seems hunger feels different in the belly of mine Vs. the cultural elites?
A cop would never drive by me causing a scene downtown hammered...but yet I manage to see that virtually daily here.
I really could beat this drum to puncture....yeah, there is a inequality or two...or three..etc.

Up 43 Down 5

Max Mack on Jul 27, 2017 at 5:16 pm

A "pan-Northern university" is not the answer. It may not even be part of the answer. A "university" will simply suck available resources from every other potential occupational training avenue, including the trades and equipment operators.

In truth, the majority of university students are female and this is even more disproportionately so in the Yukon - particularly among First Nations. Diverting resources into a "Northern university" will very likely make the situation even worse for aboriginal males.
What the North needs is high-paying jobs in occupations that First Nations men aspire to, not pointless degrees in pretend universities.

Up 47 Down 16

Jc on Jul 27, 2017 at 4:58 pm

"Unemployment rates differ substantially between indigenous and non-indigenous people in the Yukon". Perhaps its because, most indigenous people don't want to be on the unemployment rolls. With the welfare packages they can enjoy, why work? Blame the governments for that problem. Start cutting back on their annual budgets and force them to go to work to feed themselves. And why should Indigenous people with higher education earn more then other races with the same qualifications? Do I smell discrimination or reverse racism here? And that "residential school thing is clouding the real issue here. It's time to put it away for good. It;s absolutely no excuse why many of these people won't work, drink and do drugs and live the life of a beggar. Let's get to the truth, then most of these problems will be solved. As long as the residential card is on the table, it will be used for profit and excuse.

Up 14 Down 13

Lost in the Yukon on Jul 27, 2017 at 4:07 pm

In 2011 HSS was seriously working on a social inclusion strategy that was intended to address inequities but the Government of the day wanted to maintain the status quo and had no interest in seeing government accountability. The end result was that those involved were removed and the initiative watered down to a meaningless document that collects dust on a shelf in the DMs office.

Up 28 Down 5

Just Sayin' on Jul 27, 2017 at 3:58 pm

Statistics can be manipulated to reflect whatever your mandate expects you to determine. If one does not consider confounding factors when completing statistical analysis, one will not be able to provide accurate conclusions. For example, the GDP in Valdez increased during the Exxon Valdez spill therefore, one can conclude that oil spills increase GDP and help economies. Point of the rant is please keep in mind when reading anything in statistics is what factors were considered and whether other studies can reproduce the results given the same mandate.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.