Whitehorse Daily Star

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

CHANGING CIRCUMSTANCES – The Rojas Martinez family, who flew to Vancouver this week facing imminent deportation, altered a letter and signatures from the Yukon Child Development Centre, according to Yukon MP Ryan Leef. The family, shown here at the Erik Nielsen Whitehorse International Airport Monday morning, nonetheless confronted the heart-wrenching choice of leaving their youngest son, a Canadian citizen, in state care or keeping the family together in Mexico.

Image title

Photo by Whitehorse Star

Yukon MP Ryan Leef

Altered letter ‘a betrayal,’ MP says

Members of the Rojas Martinez family,

By Christopher Reynolds on February 26, 2015

Members of the Rojas Martinez family, Whitehorse residents who attracted national attention this week as they face imminent deportation, may have altered documents and signatures to heighten their chances of staying in Canada, says Yukon MP Ryan Leef.

Sergio Rojas and Linda Martinez recently made a last-ditch plea to the Immigration department to let them remain in the country on compassionate grounds due to the medical condition of their three- year-old son Jonathan, a Canadian citizen.

The couple claimed Jonathan, who suffers from skull deformation and a neck muscle disorder, requires daily attention — supposedly unavailable in Mexico, Rojas’s home country — for a dire condition, though studies suggest otherwise.

Leef told the Star this morning he has discovered that a letter from the Yukon Child Development Centre critical to their remaining on Canadian soil had been “altered” and “embellished” without consent.

The parents appear to have beefed up the urgency and extent of Jonathan’s treatment, he said.

“They in fact didn’t just embellish; they added lines about the quality of care and review for what Mexico could provide ... effectively saying that there were limited facilities in Mexico, effectively painting a picture that Canada would be the only location — if in fact any of this were needed at all,” Leef said.

“Signatures on the letter were then changed.”

Leef, who spoke with the family twice last weekend and met with Immigration Minister Chris Alexander on Monday, said he will be stepping back from the case but has forwarded all the relevant facts and documents to Citizenship and Immigration Canada. These include the altered lines and forged signatures.

“It’s my opinion that it’s no longer in the public interest of Yukoners or Canadians for me to continue to advocate for the family,” Leef said from Ottawa.

The MP labelled the alterations a “betrayal” and stressed “the integrity of our system.

“The manipulation of any process is unfair to any others who with their time, with their money, their personal effort and sometimes tremendous sacrifice, follow the law to achieve Canadian citizenship and Canadian residency.

“Taking advantage of that only risks generating future reluctance to support people who are truly in need,” he said.

Last year, the Department of Immigration rejected the family’s two consecutive appeals for permanent residency on compassionate and humanitarian grounds, granted in cases when applicants “would suffer excessive hardship” by returning to their home country.

Leef said the discovery shows that “the process works.”

He had previously emphasized his willingness to guide the family through red tape and offer limited advice, but also underscored the independence of the immigration review process.

Citizens want to know that their political representatives “are going to act with their head as much as their heart,” he added.

He further noted the discovery puts him in an embarrassing spot with the minister. Immigration officials deal with more than 10,000 files everyday, and Leef had them rush the Rojas Martinez case “to the front.”

He also said there is “more information at our disposal that I cannot discuss” which casts the family in an unfavourable light.

Leef said earlier this week that a lack of dire medical urgency may be somewhat beside the point.

“Jonathan is a Yukon-born resident. He’s a Canadian citizen. He’s one of ours.”

He emphasized the de facto deportation of a local toddler.

“This is effectively sending away a Canadian citizen,” Leef told the Star Monday.

“It’s incumbent upon us to some degree that we understand the fate to which we’re sending people and that we’re not guessing at it.”

The child development centre told the Star today it could not comment on individual cases.

The Yukon Human Rights Commission added its voice to the discussion this week, without knowledge of the apparent falsifications.

Jessica Thompson, director of human rights for the commission, urged the government “to take all opportunities to be a leader in the field of human rights and to reflect and promote Canadian values under the Charter,” CBC radio reported today.

The family was in Vancouver awaiting departure to Mexico — as ordered by the federal government — when news of the apparent falsifications broke.

Jonathan suffers from plagiocephaly — sometimes referred to as “flat head syndrome” — and congenital torticollis.

He spent much of each week at the child development centre and has received treatment at the B.C. Children’s Hospital.

Plagiocephaly, a malformation of the skull that can develop in the womb or during birth, is “considered a medically benign condition,” according to a study published by the National Institute of Health in 2005.

A B.C. Children’s Hospital summary from 2008, co-written by the institution’s former head of pediatric neurosurgery, wrote that plagiocephaly “is not thought to be associated with developmental delays or other medical issues, but the effect on cosmetic appearance can cause significant parental concern.”

Symptoms of torticollis in newborns and infants include neck muscle damage, especially on one side, which can lead to a flattened head from consistently lying or resting on the same side, according to the Stanford Children’s Health network.

Comments (16)

Up 14 Down 20

Frank Michigan on Feb 28, 2015 at 10:54 am

@waveydavey I have nothing against Ryan but do find it offensive that he had such an abrupt turnaround on his support for this family . Was there more to it that he did not disclose? He could have been far more understanding and delicate.

This is an excerpt from outside news. I am sure you can find similar news articles in Whitehorse media if you spend some time.

"Then the judge turned to a lesser charge that Ryan named the wrong place where the animal was killed when filling out an export form for his Colorado client’s trophy.
But he figured Ryan had made a careless mistake and acquitted him.

“None of us are perfect,” the judge said. “We got rid of the last person who some thought was perfect a couple of thousand years ago.” Yukon’s Supreme Court wasn’t so obliging. It found Ryan guilty of making a false statement on the export form."

Up 20 Down 4

DMZ on Feb 27, 2015 at 9:41 pm

Frank Michigan is correct about Ryan's history. This is actually an unusual case for me of feeling for Ryan, it's one of the few times he's stuck his neck out and it appears he's suffered some embarrassment with his party for it. But while I don't like to hang on to grudges, it's an awfully neat, one might say, karmic, tie-in with his own experience in the courts. It's always bugged me because nobody bothered to mention it when he was running for election, except for a Toronto paper.

Nevertheless, his heart genuinely seemed to be in the right place for this one, so better luck next time, Ryan. Next time you take on a cause, that is.

Up 5 Down 13

Betrayed Canadians on Feb 27, 2015 at 8:28 pm

Mr. Leaf isn't embellishing, altering, forging signatures on documents the same as redacting those documents. This is a term that has become all too familiar with Canadians since the Conservative Government has been in power nationally. e.g.: the Oda affair, Del Mastero, In and Out tax fraud receipts, again and again ...
This is a betrayal by those that we have entrusted the most. Despicable!

Up 27 Down 6

waveydavey on Feb 27, 2015 at 3:14 pm

Frank Michigan - are you sure about Leef's guilt regarding outfitting document falsification? I seem to recall it was Itschenko . (they do look kind of similar , I grant you that ) .

Up 42 Down 32

Frank Michigan on Feb 27, 2015 at 10:56 am

I recall Ryan Leef was charged with falsifying documents related to has outfitting business.
He therefore knows what it's like to get called out on a breach of the law. He should have been much more delicate when discussing an alleged “altered” and “embellished” letter.

Ryan, you went from your finest moment to being a person who is deeply flawed.

Up 43 Down 8

Leslie Marie on Feb 27, 2015 at 10:20 am

Why were they here in the first place? And trying to claim refugee status from Mexico? Even before finding out about the falsified documents I said they should be deported anyways. But nooo, everyone was on their side. Now? Another immigrant wanting Canada to take care of them. Take care of our own first. I'm pretty sure the Yukon residents wouldn't want their tax dollars to pay for say, P.E.I's municipal bills. Just saying.

Up 40 Down 4

Leandro Font on Feb 27, 2015 at 9:28 am

Hello there, I think this unacceptable, but I would like to say that not every Latino is like that, we have people that work hard and help society to grow and contribute to the development of our community, and it would be an act of prejudice to judge all Latino based on this case, thank you.

Up 10 Down 48

Gayle Moore on Feb 26, 2015 at 11:53 pm

All is under the "bridge". The child is a Canadian. End of story! Leave them in Canada....with provisions, no Social Assistance cheque, no Disability cheque. Work and earn your way here to show your Canadian children what it means to labour for our country! That is what we Canadians do!

Up 41 Down 10

north_of_60 on Feb 26, 2015 at 7:06 pm

"The Yukon Human Rights Commission added its voice to the discussion this week, without knowledge..."
That appears to be the NDP experience as well.

Perhaps this will be a valuable lesson for all politicians to do their due diligence before jumping on some popular bandwagon. Otherwise it looks too much like pandering for votes instead of speaking knowledgeably.

Mr Leef did the right thing by admitting the mistake and taking corrective action when he became aware of the truth. It will be interesting to see what the NDP and human rights folks have to say.

Up 17 Down 0

Adele Sandrock on Feb 26, 2015 at 5:04 pm

Is their oldest son not born in the US?

Up 105 Down 17

ProScience Greenie on Feb 26, 2015 at 4:40 pm

Nice to see Leef step up and admit he went a bit overboard and to provide some more details. Wonder how Stick, Hansen and the others will spin it?

Up 91 Down 99

Frank Michigan on Feb 26, 2015 at 4:02 pm

Maybe they altered the document out of desperation or were coached to do so.
Remember, they have lived in Yukon for awhile, they do want to stay in Canada and their son has the medical conditions, and their son is a Canadian.

It's unfortunate Ryan not only does not support them anymore, and he is attacking them. What about the local golf course caper - we know it was very wrong and everyone involved is still around. This poor family may have crossed the line in an attempt for a better life but many people are very quick to vilify them.

I guess the message is it's bad to create a false or embellished story unless you are on a golf course board, a senior public servant or a member of the legislature.

Up 107 Down 8

Bobby Bitman on Feb 26, 2015 at 3:58 pm

I'll never hold it against a person that they have a heart and are maybe a bit too trusting. Ryan believed them and took the case forward for them. He followed through and found out the facts, and now he is publicly stating that he does not think their immigration would be good for the Yukon or Canada, which is pretty direct - he's not mincing words.

I figured right from the get go that this whole deal did not pass the smell test. For me, the lack of any apparent participation in the work force by either parent told a story. They were here for years and had work permits. They did not try all that hard to contribute to Canada. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Up 76 Down 16

no compassion on Feb 26, 2015 at 3:41 pm

This is terrible. Get them out of here as soon as we can.

Up 47 Down 28

haha on Feb 26, 2015 at 3:18 pm

Maybe his assistant in Whitehorse should have caught that in September, or been better prepared to make him not look like a joke by going to bat and having to back away.

Up 74 Down 56

Thomas Brewer on Feb 26, 2015 at 3:02 pm

That's some serious backpedaling Mr. Leef is doing. Perhaps he should have done a little/lot more up front investigation before jumping on this bandwagon so fervently.

But then I suppose he wanted the media exposure being an election year and all.
Sure looks like the immigration investigators had indeed done their job.... perhaps Mr. Leef owes them an apology.

Add your comments or reply via Twitter @whitehorsestar

In order to encourage thoughtful and responsible discussion, website comments will not be visible until a moderator approves them. Please add comments judiciously and refrain from maligning any individual or institution. Read about our user comment and privacy policies.

Your name and email address are required before your comment is posted. Otherwise, your comment will not be posted.